New York Attorney General’s Office, Press Release September 21,2021
NEW YORK – New York Attorney General Letitia James and New York Police Department (NYPD) Commissioner Dermot Shea today announced the indictment of 10 members of an auto theft and distribution operation for their roles in the theft and/or criminal possession of 45 vehicles during a six-month period and their roles related to the theft and resale of more than 225 vehicles throughout New York City and Westchester. The 303-count indictment is a result of a two-year joint investigation by the Office of the Attorney General’s Organized Crime Task Force (OCTF) and the NYPD’s Auto Crime Division.
“For two years, these individuals have fueled fear in our communities and taken some of peoples’ most valuable assets,” said Attorney General James. “During the pandemic, they moved this operation into high gear, taking advantage of New Yorkers’ staying at home to allegedly stealing more than 45 cars in six months. We exhausted every avenue to track down these thieves, and, today, we send a loud and clear message that we will not stand idly by as New Yorkers are burglarized. New Yorkers deserve to feel safe in their neighborhoods, and we thank the NYPD for their partnership and support in this effort.”
“This was a complex, high-tech operation that sought to weaponize every hidden vulnerability in the automotive industry from creating keys based on bootleg code lists to altering computer settings to creating a mill that furnished false registrations for altered VIN numbers,” said NYPD Commissioner Shea. “Being an operation that never missed a chance to exploit vulnerability, it also turned up the volume of thefts during the pandemic, knowing that people were homebound or sick. I want to thank the investigators from the NYPD’s Auto Crime Division, as well as the prosecutors from the Office of the Attorney General’s Organized Crime Task Force for recognizing the seriousness and complexity of this case and building a solid prosecution.”
The investigation — dubbed “Operation Master Key,” due to the ability of the theft crews to create keys to gain access to vehicles — revealed auto theft crew members Norberto Pena Brito, Jose Lebron Pimentel, Edwin Hidalgo Estevez, Dariberto Fernandez Perez, and Hector Rivera were responsible for locating, stealing, altering, and reselling stolen vehicles throughout New York City and Westchester.
From April 2020 to October 2020 — during the months the state was shut down due to the pandemic and New Yorkers stayed at home and parked their cars for days at a time — this crew scoped out and targeted cars to steal, obtained key code information for these vehicles from unlawful websites, and created keys that allowed them to breach and steal the vehicles. Once inside of the vehicle, they reprogrammed the vehicle’s computer system to gain control of the vehicle, disable alarms, and start the engine. In a matter of minutes, the theft crew was able to steal a vehicle without sounding alarms or drawing any attention, even in a dense urban setting. The theft crew was also able to reprogram the vehicle to stop recognizing the true owners’ electronic keys, so that the owners’ keys stopped working.
Members of this organization then transported the vehicles back to one of several lots located in the Bronx, where the vehicles were altered and the vehicle identification numbers (VINs) were changed in order to give the stolen cars a new identity. Jesus Cabral was hired to remove and replace windshields and to change vehicle VINs assigned by the manufacturer. At times, Norberto Pena Brito and Jose Lebron Pimentel would also buy stolen cars from Carlos Valverde. Afterwards, crew members sold the stolen cars to their customers, including to Willy Abreu Martinez and Abdul Khan, who were two of the high-volume customers purchasing the stolen cars for resale in the United States and in the Dominican Republic. Leticia Saldivar — the owner and operator of Carmela’s Multiservice and Auto Tag in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania — was recruited to obtain, organize, and file fictitious vehicle documents with the Pennsylvania Department of Transportation, and obtained clean registrations and titles for stolen vehicles.
This joint investigation included hundreds of hours of physical and covert surveillance, court-authorized wiretapping of numerous targeted phones, execution of search warrants, and the recovery of surveillance video capturing the thefts of numerous vehicles.
The 303-count indictment — unsealed today in Bronx County State Supreme Court — charges the 10 individuals with numerous counts of Criminal Possession of Stolen Property in the Second and Third Degrees (Class C and D felonies), Grand Larceny in the Third Degree (Class D felony), Offering a False Instrument for Filing in the First Degree (Class E felony), Criminal Possession of a Forged Instrument in the Second Degree (Class D felony), Conspiracy in the Fourth and Fifth Degrees (Class E felony and Class A Misdemeanor), and related charges for conspiring to steal, possess, and sell 45 stolen vehicles, and also conspiring to register stolen cars in the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania by filing forged vehicle documents.
If convicted, defendants Carlos Valverde and Leticia Saldivar each face a maximum of seven years of prison. The remaining defendants face a maximum of 15 years in prison.
Those charged in today’s unsealed indictment include:
NORBERTO PENA BRITO – 35 years old, Bronx, NY
JOSE LEBRON PIMENTEL – 39 years old, Bronx, NY
EDWIN HIDALGO ESTEVEZ – 31 years old, Bronx, NY
DARIBERTO FERNANDEZ PEREZ – 30 years old, Bronx, NY
HECTOR RIVERA – 52 years old, Bronx, NY
JESUS CABRAL – 55 years old, Waterbury, CT
WILLY ABREU MARTINEZ – 39 years old, Bronx, NY
ABDUL KHAN – 35 years old, Bronx, NY
CARLOS VALVERDE – 33 years old, Bronx, NY
LETICIA SALDIVAR – 37 years old, Waterford Works, NJ
The charges against the defendants are merely accusations and the defendants are presumed innocent unless and until proven guilty.
The charges in the indictment are the result of a joint investigation by the OAG’s OCTF and the NYPD's Auto Crime Division. The OAG would like to thank the Yonkers Police Department; the Pennsylvania State Police; the Police Department for the City of Reading Pennsylvania; the Bureau of Police for the City of Lancaster, Pennsylvania; the Massachusetts State Police; the New Jersey State Police; the Miami-Dade Metro Police Department; U.S. Customs and Border Protection; U.S. Department of Homeland Security Investigations; U.S. Marshals New York/New Jersey Regional Fugitive Task Force; the Vermont Division of Motor Vehicles; the Pennsylvania Department of Transportation; the New York Department of Motor Vehicles; the National Insurance Crime Bureau; and the National Automotive Service Task Force for their valuable participation in this investigation.
The investigation was jointly led by NYPD Auto Crime Division Detective Daniel Fox and OAG OCTF Detective David Walsh. Detective Fox is under the supervision of Lieutenant Jorge Rodriguez and the overall supervision of Deputy Inspector Robert LaPollo. Detective Walsh is under the supervision of Supervising Detective Bradford Miller and the overall supervision of Deputy Chief John McManus of the OAG's Investigations Bureau. The OAG's Investigations Bureau is led by Chief Investigator Oliver Pu-Folks.
The case is being prosecuted by OAG OCTF Assistant Deputy Attorney General Ann Lee, with the assistance of Legal Support Analyst Stephanie Tirado — both under the supervision of Downstate OCTF Deputy Chief Lauren Abinanti. Special thanks to Assistant Deputy Attorney General Caitlin Carroll and former Special Counsel Shanon LaCorte. Nicole Keary is the Deputy Attorney General in Charge of OCTF. Both the Investigations Bureau and OCTF are part of the Division for Criminal Justice. The Division for Criminal Justice is led by Chief Deputy Attorney General José Maldonado and overseen by First Deputy Attorney General Jennifer Levy.